HighDots.NET Computer Hardware Forums  

Will the new E6x20 procs OC better?

Hardware Overclocking Discussions about overclocking (alt.comp.hardware.overclocking)


Discuss Will the new E6x20 procs OC better? in the Hardware Overclocking forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1  
Old   
Phil, Non-Squid
 
Posts: n/a

Default Will the new E6x20 procs OC better? - 04-05-2007 , 02:16 AM






I was reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Core_2 and noticed that
there will be the Core 2 Duo E6540 and E6550 for the same big-lot price as
E6300 and upcoming E6320 chips ($163) Does anyone know if these will have
big benefits to OCing since the 6540 and 6550 will be typically running at
1333 FSB? In other words, should I wait for these to come out for my new
build? I'm guessing they'll work find on a typical OC board with 400+Mhz
capabilites...

--
Phil



Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old   
Phil, Non-Squid
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Will the new E6x20 procs OC better? - 04-05-2007 , 12:18 PM






Phil, Non-Squid wrote:
Quote:
I was reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Core_2 and noticed
that there will be the Core 2 Duo E6540 and E6550 for the same
big-lot price as E6300 and upcoming E6320 chips ($163) Does anyone
know if these will have big benefits to OCing since the 6540 and 6550
will be typically running at 1333 FSB? In other words, should I wait
for these to come out for my new build? I'm guessing they'll work
find on a typical OC board with 400+Mhz capabilites...
Nevermind, I found the xbit article here:
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu...duo-e6420.html

The E6420 is on retail preorder for between $200-$210 retail right now.

Looks like an excellent time to be on Intel.

--
Phil




Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old   
Thomas
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Will the new E6x20 procs OC better? - 04-06-2007 , 08:38 AM



Phil, Non-Squid wrote:
Quote:
I was reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Core_2 and noticed
that there will be the Core 2 Duo E6540 and E6550 for the same
big-lot price as E6300 and upcoming E6320 chips ($163) Does anyone
know if these will have big benefits to OCing since the 6540 and 6550
will be typically running at 1333 FSB? In other words, should I wait
for these to come out for my new build? I'm guessing they'll work
find on a typical OC board with 400+Mhz capabilites...
In general, it's easier to OC a processor with lower FSB, since OC'ing can
only be achieved by making the FSB higher... This is why it's more
interesting to get the E4300 processor, which has an 800 'MHz' FSB. This can
easily be lifted to 1066 'MHz' and higher, not requiring special chipsets.

--
Met vriendelijke groeten, Thomas vd Horst.




Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old   
Phil, Non-Squid
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Will the new E6x20 procs OC better? - 04-06-2007 , 11:41 AM



Thomas wrote:
Quote:
Phil, Non-Squid wrote:
I was reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Core_2 and noticed
that there will be the Core 2 Duo E6540 and E6550 for the same
big-lot price as E6300 and upcoming E6320 chips ($163) Does anyone
know if these will have big benefits to OCing since the 6540 and 6550
will be typically running at 1333 FSB? In other words, should I wait
for these to come out for my new build? I'm guessing they'll work
find on a typical OC board with 400+Mhz capabilites...

In general, it's easier to OC a processor with lower FSB, since
OC'ing can only be achieved by making the FSB higher... This is why
it's more interesting to get the E4300 processor, which has an 800
'MHz' FSB. This can easily be lifted to 1066 'MHz' and higher, not
requiring special chipsets.
Conversely, do you also mean that it's easier to OC a proc with a higher
multiplier?
--
Phil




Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old   
Thomas
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Will the new E6x20 procs OC better? - 04-06-2007 , 11:58 AM



Phil, Non-Squid wrote:
Quote:
Thomas wrote:
Phil, Non-Squid wrote:
I was reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Core_2 and
noticed that there will be the Core 2 Duo E6540 and E6550 for the
same big-lot price as E6300 and upcoming E6320 chips ($163) Does
anyone know if these will have big benefits to OCing since the
6540 and 6550 will be typically running at 1333 FSB? In other
words, should I wait for these to come out for my new build? I'm
guessing they'll work find on a typical OC board with 400+Mhz
capabilites...

In general, it's easier to OC a processor with lower FSB, since
OC'ing can only be achieved by making the FSB higher... This is why
it's more interesting to get the E4300 processor, which has an 800
'MHz' FSB. This can easily be lifted to 1066 'MHz' and higher, not
requiring special chipsets.

Conversely, do you also mean that it's easier to OC a proc with a
higher multiplier?
Err... yep :-) Sometimes I have problems expressing myself clearly, even in
my native language, hehe...

--
Met vriendelijke groeten, Thomas vd Horst.




Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old   
Phil, Non-Squid
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Will the new E6x20 procs OC better? - 04-06-2007 , 11:59 AM



Phil, Non-Squid wrote:
Quote:
Thomas wrote:
Phil, Non-Squid wrote:
I was reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Core_2 and noticed
that there will be the Core 2 Duo E6540 and E6550 for the same
big-lot price as E6300 and upcoming E6320 chips ($163) Does anyone
know if these will have big benefits to OCing since the 6540 and
6550 will be typically running at 1333 FSB? In other words, should
I wait for these to come out for my new build? I'm guessing
they'll work find on a typical OC board with 400+Mhz capabilites...

In general, it's easier to OC a processor with lower FSB, since
OC'ing can only be achieved by making the FSB higher... This is why
it's more interesting to get the E4300 processor, which has an 800
'MHz' FSB. This can easily be lifted to 1066 'MHz' and higher, not
requiring special chipsets.
I think I'm beginning to understand. Lower FSB means higher multipliers
which means easier overclocking? Or do you mean that the percentage
improvement for that one chip is greater? Will an E4300 OC to as high of a
top speed as well as an E6x00 series, all else being equal?

Quote:
Conversely, do you also mean that it's easier to OC a proc with a
higher multiplier?
This is what my impressions are:

1. High FSB stresses the NB/SB more but makes fine-tuning easier, as long as
the PCI/AGP/memory buses can be divided to stay at their respective rates.
2. High multipliers are a good thing
3. Mem/PCI/AGP can be held completely independent of the FSB when the
motherboard supports their dividers, thus making the two dependent variables
the FSB and the NB/SB frequencies and temperatures.

Is this somewhat correct? Thanks all.
--
Phil




Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old   
Phil, Non-Squid
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: Will the new E6x20 procs OC better? - 04-07-2007 , 02:57 AM



Phil Weldon wrote:
Quote:
'Phil, Non-Squid' wrote, in part:
I think I'm beginning to understand. Lower FSB means higher
multipliers which means easier overclocking? Or do you mean that
the percentage improvement for that one chip is greater? Will an
E4300 OC to as high of a top speed as well as an E6x00 series, all
else being equal?
.
2. High multipliers are a good thing
.
_____

Not exactly.

High multipliers are a necessary evil.

The CPU clock is MUCH faster than the memory clock (memory speeds
have not kept up with processor speeds and CPUs of the Pentium 4 and
later classes are 'super-scalar' (can complete more than one
instruction per clock cycle.)

*** A higher multiplier means the memory clock is even lower compared
to the CPU clock (and the speed gap is even greater.)

The higher the multiplier, the greater the relative penalty when the
CPU must access memory.

Mitigating factor: L1 and L2 caches greatly reduce access time
whenever the data/instructions needed are already in the cache (it is
not necessary to access main memory; the L1 and L2 caches clock at
the CPU rate, though there is a small penalty when the L1 cache must
be used and a larger penalty when the L2 cache must be used. Access
is still much faster than when the data/instructions are not in the
L1 or L2 caches.

*** Given two CPUs with the same clock speed, but with different
multipliers, the one with the LOWER multiplier will perform better
because the FSB speed must be higher, and memory access will be
faster IF the memory can run at the same CPU : memory clock ratio.

(E4300 @ 1.8 GHz, multiplier of 9X, 800 MHz FSB, 200 MHz CPU clock,
CPU clock : memory clock ratio of 1:1)
(E6300 @ 1.86 GHz, multiplier of 7X, 1066 MHz FSB, 266 MHz CPU
clock, CPU clock : memory clock ratio of 1:1)

When the above two CPUs are NOT overclocked, the E6300 will have a
slight advantage because the CPU can execute instructions slightly
faster AND because memory can be accessed faster AND the gap between
the CPU speed and the memory access speed is lower.

But when you overclock, the FSB speed must be raised.

If the memory is limited to operation at PC8500 ( 266 MHz) clock then
the E4300 FSB must be set to 1066 MHz (266 MHz X 9 = 2.4 GHz) and the
CPU : memory clock ratio can be kept at 1:1. This gives a CPU speed
of 2.4 GHz.

With the same memory performance limit, to get the same CPU speed
with the E6300, the FSB speed must be set to 1372 MHz ( 343 MHz X 7 =
2.4 GHz) but the CPU : memory clock ratio must be set to 4:3 (or 5:4
if the memory can be pushed a few extra MHz).

The two CPUs now have the same speed and about the same memory access
speed because the CPU : memory clock ratio must be set to 4:3 for the
E6300. The performance is now the same, BUT the 1372 MHz FSB
necessary for an E6300 @
2.4 GHz pushes the limits of the motherboard while the 1066 MHz FSB
for the E4300 does not. This becomes an even more critical factor
when larger overclocks are attempted. The E4300 and the E6300 can
easily operate above
3.0 GHz but the E6300 will be limited by the motherboard FSB
capability at a much lower overclock than the E4300.

For E4300 vs. E6300 performance, the E6300 wins by a relatively small
margin at stock speed and low overclock percentages but a E4300 is
capable of higher overclock percentages.
Perfect! I understand better now. Thanks.
--
Phil




Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.